MFA Storm
Dana Whitfield, the finance director, woke up to dozens of MFA prompts on her phone. She thinks she tapped Approve on one at 3am to make them stop. A supplier has just emailed asking why Contoso changed its bank details.
Three locks to open
- 1Find the break-in. Did the attacker get in, and from where?
- 2Contain it. Close every way back in, not just the obvious one.
- 3Prove it. Run the containment check.
My phone went off all night with sign-in requests. I think I pressed Approve once just to make it stop. Sorry.
Now a supplier says we emailed them new bank details yesterday? I never sent that.
I'm on a train with no laptop. Treat it as a compromised account. Work out what they did once they were in, and close all of it.
You escaped MFA Storm
What happened
An attacker had Dana's password and spammed her with MFA prompts overnight until she approved one at 03:14. Within minutes they registered their own Microsoft Authenticator ('Phone') so they wouldn't need Dana again, and created an inbox rule called '.' that forwarded anything about invoices, payments or bank details to an outside address and deleted it from her inbox. They then emailed a supplier new bank details from her account.
How you'd fix it for real
- Find the successful sign-in among the denied MFA prompts, and note the IP address.
- Check what that IP address did afterwards: security info registered, inbox rules, mail sent.
- Reset the password, remove any authentication method the user didn't add, and delete malicious inbox rules.
- Revoke sessions last, so the attacker can't sign straight back in. Existing access tokens can last up to an hour unless the app supports continuous access evaluation.
- Tell finance and the supplier, check sent items and mail flow for anything else, and report it.
Stop it happening again
- Teach people to deny prompts they didn't start, and to report them as suspicious activity.
- Move high-risk users like finance to phishing-resistant MFA such as passkeys.
- Use risk-based Conditional Access so a sign-in from an unfamiliar hosting provider is challenged or blocked.
- Alert on new inbox rules that forward mail outside the organisation, and block automatic external forwarding.